Exhibit #22  Copy of an excerpt of the 1870 U.S. Federal Census enumeration for
James B. Marvin with his (second) wife Lydia E. and daughter Florence.
Exhibit #23 Copy of an excerpt of the 1875 New York State Census enumeration of
James C. Marvin, with his (second) wife Lydia E. and children Mary L.
and Flora A.
Exhibit #24  Copy of an excerpt of the 1880 U.S. Federal Census enumeration for Jas.
B. Marvin, his wife Emma J, and daughter Mary.
Exhibit #25   Biography of James B- Marvin, published in the "Historical Gazetteer and
Biographical Memorial of Cattaraugus Co. NY”, ed by William Adams,
1893, History of the Town of Perrysburg - Chapter XLI (41) p. 956,
which reports that he married Hester A. Watkins, of Pembroke, N. Y., by
whom he had one daughter, Florence A. His second wife was Lydia E.
Robbins…they have one daughter, Mary L....Florence Marvin married
Daniel Wagner and has one daughter, Alice.
The State of New York did not keep vital records prior to 1880, and no record of the
death of Hester / Esther A. Watkins Marvin has been located. No record was located of
Hester / Esther A. Watkins Marvin or James B. Marvin in Cattaraugus County
cemeteries. No probate record was located for James B. Marvin in Cattaraugus County,
New York Wilt Testators index from 1830 to 1916.
The issue of Hester / Esther A. Watkins Marvin follows:
01.   Florence A. Marvin Wagner (First cousin of the half blood of the decedent)
According to our research and the attached documentation, Florence A. Marvin was born
February 16, 1864 or 1865 in Akron, New York, a daughter of Esther A. Watkins Marvin
and James B. Marvin. She married Daniel H. Wagner and they had two issue; namely,
Alice Marvin and a child who died prior to 1892. Florence A. Marvin Wagner died April
15, 1914 at Horseheads. New York. Attached hereto are:
            Exhibit #26  Copy of an excerpt of the 1880 U.S. Federal Census enumeration for
                     Philip Wagner, his wife Effie, son Daniel, daughter-in-law Florence, and
                     son Philip.
Exhibit #27  Copy of an excerpt of the 1900 U.S. Federal Census enumeration for
                     Florence Wagner (mother of two children, one of whom is living) and her
                      daughter Alice F.

8